Cleanroom Projects Management: Challenges in Engineering, Procurement, and Construction

Cleanroom facilities are crucial for industries such as pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, semiconductors, aerospace, and electronics, where contamination control is imperative. Managing a cleanroom project is a highly intricate process, requiring an exceptional level of planning and precision.

Given the sensitive nature of cleanrooms, projects in this domain present unique challenges that span across engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) phases. This article navigates these challenges and offers insight into effective strategies for overcoming them.

The Importance of Cleanroom Design

A cleanroom is a controlled environment where factors such as temperature, humidity, and particulate matter are carefully monitored and maintained. The design of a cleanroom is influenced by specific requirements such as the type of production / process, the grade of cleanliness needed, and the equipment and processes involved. The design must also consider the airflow patterns, filtration systems, lighting, electrical layout, utility integration, and most importantly hazards arising from the process(es) under consideration (i.e. dealing with flammables).

In the engineering phase, cleanroom projects require specialized expertise to create designs that meet stringent industry codes and standards. Challenges include aligning the engineering design with the client’s requirements, local building codes, and regulatory standards such as ISO 14644 for air cleanliness or FDA regulations for pharmaceutical cleanrooms. The project team must ensure that all systems are compatible, energy-efficient, and capable of meeting the rigorous contamination control criteria

Engineering Challenges

1. Complexity of Design: Cleanroom design is a highly technical process that requires careful integration of HVAC systems, air filters, environmental monitoring systems, and structural components. Coordinating these various aspects is challenging, especially when each system must meet specific standards of cleanliness and efficiency.
2. Customization and Flexibility: Cleanrooms often need to be customized based on the client’s specific needs, which adds complexity to the design process. Unlike typical building projects, cleanroom designs are highly specialized, making it difficult to reuse designs from previous projects without significant adjustments.

3. Regulatory Compliance: Engineering teams must ensure that all systems comply with stringent industry regulations. Failure to meet these standards can lead to costly delays, additional costs for redesign, and potential legal consequences.
4. Integration with Existing Infrastructure: Many cleanroom projects are retrofits in existing facilities, which presents a unique set of engineering challenges. The new cleanroom systems must be seamlessly integrated with existing electrical, plumbing, and HVAC systems without causing disruption to ongoing operations.

Procurement Challenges

The procurement phase of a cleanroom project involves acquiring the necessary materials, equipment, and services to build the facility. This phase is crucial for maintaining project timelines, quality, and cost efficiency. However, cleanroom procurement comes with its own set of hurdles.

1. Specialized Equipment and Materials: The materials and equipment required for cleanrooms are specialized and often come with long lead times. For example, air filtration systems, high-performance HVAC systems, and sterile furniture can take several months to procure, which can delay project timelines. Additionally, sourcing materials that meet the required standards without exceeding budget constraints can be a delicate balancing act.
2. Cost Control: Cleanroom projects are often high-cost endeavors, with expenses driven by specialized materials and equipment. Procurement teams must negotiate with suppliers, ensuring that they meet quality standards without overshooting the project’s budget. Supply chain disruptions, rising material costs, and unexpected delivery delays can further complicate procurement and impact project schedules.
3. Vendor Coordination: Given the number of specialized systems and materials required, coordination between multiple vendors and contractors is essential. The procurement team must ensure that all vendors are working from the same timeline and that there is minimal overlap or conflict in the materials and systems they provide.
4. Lead Time Variability: Sourcing the right components, such as HEPA filters, air handling units, and other cleanroom-specific products, can take time, and unforeseen delays are common. Procuring items early in the project and having contingency plans for delays can mitigate this risk, but it is still a significant challenge.

Construction Challenges

The construction phase of a cleanroom project is where the design and procurement come to execution. However, the construction of a cleanroom is unlike traditional building projects due to the specific environmental controls required and the need for absolute cleanliness during construction.

1. Maintaining Cleanliness During Construction: One of the biggest challenges in cleanroom construction is maintaining the desired level of cleanliness during the build. Construction workers need to take special precautions to minimize dust, debris, and other contaminants from entering the cleanroom environment. Special protective coverings must be used, and the construction site must be meticulously cleaned to minimize contamination, hence, minimize the cost of cleaning before certification.
2. Sequencing of Work: Construction activities must be carefully sequenced to ensure that all systems, such as electrical and HVAC, are installed before cleanroom panels and finishes are put in place. Additionally, the installation of systems like air handling units and filtration systems must be coordinated to ensure proper airflow once the cleanroom is operational. Improper sequencing can result in costly rework or delays, this is strongly dependent on-site conditions, lead times and other site circumstances.

3. Testing and Commissioning: Once the construction is complete, cleanroom systems must undergo rigorous testing to ensure they meet performance specifications. This includes testing air pressure, temperature, humidity, and particle levels, as well as confirming that equipment such as air filters and HVAC systems are functioning as required. Any discrepancies in these tests can delay the project or require costly adjustments.
4. Personnel and Labor Coordination: The construction phase often involves a mix of highly specialized contractors, which can lead to coordination challenges. Specialized subcontractors responsible for cleanroom systems need to work in close collaboration with other trades to ensure that systems are installed properly and in compliance with design specifications. Miscommunication or errors during installation can lead to delays and cost overruns.

Conclusion

Managing a cleanroom project is a complex task that requires expertise across various domains. From the engineering phase, with its complex design requirements and regulatory challenges, to procurement, where specialized equipment and materials must be sourced efficiently, to the construction phase, which demands high standards of execution and precise coordination, the challenges are numerous.

At ACH Engineering, we have the expertise and proven processes to tackle the challenges of building cleanroom and controlled environment spaces. Let us help you bring your project to life with seamless execution and exceptional results.

Contact us today to discuss your upcoming project!

---

Transform Your Controlled Environment Today

Ready to create a high-performance cleanroom or controlled environment? Let ACH Engineering guide you from design to completion.