User Requirement Specification for Cleanrooms

In industries where precision, cleanliness, and environmental control are crucial—such as pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, microelectronics, aerospace, and semiconductor manufacturing—cleanrooms and controlled environments are essential.

These spaces are carefully designed and maintained to meet stringent requirements to ensure product integrity and quality. However, before building or upgrading a cleanroom or controlled environment, one of the most critical steps is developing a comprehensive and accurate User Requirement Specification (URS).

What is URS?

A User Requirement Specification (URS) is a document that outlines the functions and requirements for a cleanroom. In addition to any regulations or standards it must adhere to, it addresses topics like temperature, air quality, and cleanliness levels. In order to ensure that the cleanroom is safe, efficient, and meets the requirements of users, the URS assists in directing the configuration and design.

A well-drafted URS is the foundation upon which cleanroom projects are built. It outlines the technical and functional needs of the customer, defines key performance indicators, and sets expectations for the design, installation, and operation of the cleanroom.

However, the optimization of the URS is not always a straightforward task. The success of a cleanroom application often hinges on a collaborative effort between the cleanroom solution provided and the customer. This collaboration helps to ensure that the final design meets both the customer’s actual requirements and their idealized desires. Striking a balance between what is truly needed versus what is wished for is key to avoiding costly missteps, project delays, and performance shortfalls.

The Role of URS in Cleanroom and Controlled Environment Design

The URS acts as the blueprint for cleanroom construction and operation. It is essentially the customer’s voice in the design process, defining the performance parameters, the level of cleanliness (e.g., ISO class), environmental controls (e.g., temperature, humidity, and airflow), and the specific applications that the cleanroom will support. URS outlines various criteria, such as:

• Airflow specifications: The air cleanliness (particulate concentration), the type of filtration required (e.g., HEPA or ULPA filters).
• Environmental conditions: Temperature, humidity, and pressure settings that must be maintained to ensure a stable environment for critical processes.
• Equipment requirements: Special tools, instruments, or machinery required within the cleanroom.
• Personnel protocols: Defined standards for personnel entry and behavior, including gowning, hygiene, and airlock systems.

However, the process of generating the URS can often become unclear with customer expectations that exceed practical or regulatory standards. This is where collaboration between the customer and the system provider is imperative.

Distinguishing Between Requirements and Wishes

A significant challenge in the URS creation is understanding the distinction between what the customer truly needs and what they might simply wish for. Customers often come into cleanroom projects with a broad vision, but they may not fully comprehend the implications of their desires. Many times, customers will overestimate their needs for certain features—whether that’s an overly stringent cleanliness class, excessive airflow rates, or complex systems for controlling temperature and humidity. These desires, while well-intentioned, might not always align with the true operational needs of the cleanroom or may exceed the practical capabilities of their budget.

In such cases, it becomes critical for the solution provider and specifically their engineering team to engage with the customer and clarify the true purpose of the cleanroom. By asking insightful questions and focusing on the core objectives of the cleanroom’s operation, the design team can separate the customer’s needs from their wishes. This is where close communication, education, and experience become vital.

1. Understanding Operational Goals

The first step in bridging the gap between requirements and wishes is understanding the customer’s operational goals. For instance, a pharmaceutical company may require a cleanroom to manufacture sterile injectable drugs. The primary objective is to maintain aseptic conditions, avoid contamination, and protect product integrity. Here, the design team needs to focus on the necessary air cleanliness level (e.g., ISO class 5) and control of particulate contamination, ensuring that the cleanroom is equipped to meet Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) standards. Any additional features, such as higher air changes or tighter temperature controls, may be nice to have but not critical for the process at hand.

2. Education Through Dialogue

Once the operational goals are understood, it is essential to educate the customer on the implications of their requirements. For example, a customer might request an ISO class 5 environment throughout the entire facility, thinking this is necessary for all stages of production. However, in reality, the cleanroom might only need this class for critical processes, while less stringent conditions would suffice for other stages. By discussing options, such as the possibility of multi-class zones or alternative configurations, the customer can better understand the costs, trade-offs, and benefits of each solution.

3. Managing Budget Constraints

A cleanroom is a significant investment, and costs can easily spiral out of control if the design parameters are driven by wishes rather than needs. For instance, the cost of equipment, specialized materials, and labor required to build an environment that exceeds operational requirements can quickly inflate a project budget. By focusing on the true operational needs and educating the customer on why certain features are necessary while others are in excess, the engineering team can help keep costs within reason.

4. Regulatory and Industry Standards

Sometimes, customers may have wishes that extend beyond industry standards or regulatory requirements. For example, a customer might request a cleanroom environment that surpasses the ISO classification recommended for their specific application.

In these cases, it’s important for the design team to highlight the compliance standards that must be adhered to. By ensuring that the customer understands the regulatory framework that governs cleanroom design, the URS can be optimized to meet both the regulatory and functional requirements while avoiding unnecessary additions.

The Benefits of Optimization

Optimizing the URS by ensuring that it reflects true requirements rather than lofty wishes offers several key benefits:

• Cost Efficiency: By aligning the design with realistic operational needs, the customer avoids spending on unnecessary upgrades, helping to keep the project within budget.
• Time Savings: A clear and well-defined URS minimizes the risk of redesigns and modifications during the construction phase, reducing project timelines.
• Operational Excellence: When the cleanroom is designed with precision to meet operational needs, it enhances efficiency, reduces downtime, and ensures compliance with regulatory standards.

The process of optimizing the User Requirement Specification for cleanroom and controlled environments is an essential part of any cleanroom design project. By working closely with the customer, cleanroom solution providers can help distinguish between actual requirements and unnecessary wishes. This collaboration not only ensures that the design meets regulatory and operational standards but also allows the customer to understand the trade-offs involved in meeting their goals. The result is a well-designed cleanroom that operates efficiently, stays within budget, and can support high-quality production processes, ultimately contributing to the long-term success of the business.

We at ACH Engineering work closely with our customers to help them tailor their URS to set the right basis for their projects by leveraging the collective experience that we gained throughout the years. Connect Now!

---

Transform Your Controlled Environment Today

Ready to create a high-performance cleanroom or controlled environment? Let ACH Engineering guide you from design to completion.